Technical Analysis -- Valuable Tool or Misguided Product of 'Beautiful Mind'?Recommendations for Self-Teaching Technical AnalysisIn the movie, “A Beautiful Mind”, university professor, John Forbes Nash Jr., suffers from schizophrenia and hallucinates that he has been engaged by the CIA to decode a foreign plot to overthrow the US Government. He looks for clues to these plots through what he believes are messages he finds in common magazines and newspapers. His hallucinations are so detailed and real in his mind that he sees and talks to an imaginary CIA agent, Parcher, played by Ed Harris.
<cut>
In many respects the public perceives technical analysts to be similar to Dr. Nash. As with Dr. Nash in “Beautiful Mind”, the public perceives technical analysts as borderline schizophrenics looking for order in random occurrences in stock market charts. Perhaps their own failures in their attempts to read stock charts lend more credence to their belief that technical analysts are practicing useless voodoo, or readings of an 8-ball, or ouija board. They get a lot of reinforcement from some writers in financial magazine publications, and cable TV. Cable often includes brief “bites” of so-called technical experts espousing analyses that are as unsound as their cheerleading analysts’ misguided stock tips.
The facts are that there is something of value in technical analysis. Human nature tends to take on repeatable patterns. Such patterns are represented on stock charts, which can be used to predict future stock moves. However, technical analysis is a discipline that is similar to counting cards at the blackjack table. You will not make money every time. Appropriate use of technical analysis will give you an edge over the market or “house” that will allow you to make money over time (including transaction costs). There are many styles and philosophies of technical analysis. The beginner should know that as with anything else of value, it requires a lot of work including education, practice, and discipline. It’s amazing how many people trade stocks based on what they think is sound technical analysis, having never even read a book or examined anything except for Internet stock message boards. That is a sure fire method for failure. Internet Chat boards are loaded with misguided hearsay posing for technical analysis. It’s a waste of time. Stay away.
Our stock market is in the midst of a speculative bubble. I agree with Warren Buffett’s observation this winter (when the stock market was much lower), that there is very little true investment value in most sectors of common stocks of US companies now. This winter, Buffett’s organization ferreted out Best Buy (BBY), stock in the low 20’s. It was sold a couple of months ago in the mid-40s, and now trades in the mid-50s. No longer a Buffett-type value by any means! There is precious little profit to be made in investing in common stocks in the fundamental buy-and-hold manner that made Warren Buffett one of the best long-term investors and richest people in the world. If you read any good book on fundamental analysis of stocks written in the 80s or before, you will find that the valuations used as examples are much lower from what we have in today’s market. If you want to be like Warren Buffett, you will have to wait for this current speculative bubble to burst. Be patient, eventually it will. In this stock market environment, to achieve positive returns while avoiding large losses you must know and apply technical analysis. To do this effectively, you must educate yourself.
"Below are my recommendations for self-education in Technical Analysis."