WSJ: Medicaid for Millionaires

[question everything]

The Wall Street Journal

Medicaid for Millionaires
February 24, 2005; Page A14

Medicaid was established in 1965 with the worthy aim of providing medical care for the poor; it was never intended as a middle-class entitlement or as inheritance protection for the children of well-off seniors. Yet the latter is precisely what has happened -- to the point that sheltering assets and income to qualify for Medicaid is now as routine as writing a will.

If you don't believe us, Google "Medicaid estate planning" on the Web and see what pops up. There's a whole "elderlaw" industry out there dedicated to the children of seniors who want to make sure that other taxpayers, not they, pay for nursing-home care via Medicaid should mom or dad ever need it. As one advertiser puts it, "You can qualify for Medicaid while preserving most assets & savings!"

Such "asset-shifting" may be morally questionable, but in most cases it is entirely legal. Anyone can give away most of his assets and three years later become eligible for Medicaid with no questions asked. Or, since a home, business and car of unlimited value are excluded from the calculation of assets, someone who wishes to qualify for Medicaid may shield his money by remodeling his house, investing in the family business, or purchasing expensive cars that he then gives away to family members (the notorious "two Mercedes rule"). Term life insurance -- also of unlimited value -- is excluded as well.

Medicaid "planners" often counsel well-to-do clients to save enough money to pay for a year of care at a private, high-quality nursing home, which under federal law can't kick you out if you then switch over to Medicaid. As Stephen Moses of the Center for Long-Term Care Financing points out, "Poor people don't have key money, so they end up in the least desirable 100%-Medicaid facilities, while the lawyers' clients occupy the scarcer Medicaid beds in nicer nursing homes." About 70% of nursing-home patients are on Medicaid.

Congress has periodically tried to clamp down on abuses but usually ends up making things worse. In 1993 it passed a law requiring states to recover the cost of benefits from the estates of deceased recipients (or from the estates of the spouses they pre-decease). This bombed, as most states make only half-hearted efforts to recover Medicaid costs. In 2002, state Medicaid programs spent $46.5 billion on nursing home care but recovered a measly $350 million from estates.

(snip)

URL for this article:
http://online.wsj.com/article/0,,SB110920966481062758,00.html

[Malva Zebrina]

1. Years ago I worked in a private nursing home

owned by doctors. There were three residents there, who were the mothers of the doctors. All three were on Medicaid.