Neck deep in the Big Muddy BY ANDREW GREELEY

[jbfam4]

Neck deep in the Big Muddy
http://www.suntimes.com/output/greeley/cst-edt-greel29.html
July 29, 2005

BY ANDREW GREELEY

The Big Muddy is deeper and darker. Two Pentagon reports this week show just how muddy. In a survey of the morale of soldiers in Iraq, the Pentagon found that more than half said that morale in their units was either "low" or "very low." Morale was especially low, as one would have expected, among the National Guard and Reserve units. Only half of them said they had "real confidence" in their ability to carry out their mission, probably because they were not trained for the kind of war in which they are involved.



People with yellow ribbons say we must support our troops. I agree completely. The best way to support them is to get them out of a war justified by falsehoods and carried out by incompetents who have tried to do it on the cheap with no idea of what they would have to face after Saddam's regime was knocked over. We must stay the course, President Bush says, but he won't specify what the course is.


The suicide bombs in Iraq kill Iraqis, but they are aimed at American occupation and will end only when the occupation ends. Conservative columnists and editorial writers are screaming that the suicide bombers in London are not angry over Iraq; they rather want to destroy our way of life. But their own testimony seems to be that they are protesting the treatment of Muslims in Iraq and Palestine. Tony Blair, the loyal junior partner in the Anglo-American alliance, is paying the price for this crazy war. When the coalition leaves Iraq the bombings in England will stop just they will in Iraq.

The screamers will say that means the "martyrs" will have defeated us. That's precisely right. They are in the process of defeating us in a war that we cannot possibly win, the war that Bush needed so he could become a wartime president. Many of those who say the war was a mistake in the first place still argue that it would be wrong to leave now. Unless the Bush administration can find a way to stop the suicide bombers -- other than the president's "disgust" -- we have no choice but to get out of the Big Muddy now.

What idiocy not to expect that the attacks on Israel by suicide bombers would spread because of the war and occupation in Iraq. Why is anyone surprised? The president tells us that they "disgust" him. Hooray for him. His supporters call them crazy fanatics as they may well be. But calling them names and demanding that the world denounce them will not put a stop to their attacks. They are beating us, and we are apparently unable to stop them, save by promising to stay the course. That is terribly frustrating to Americans, but that's a price they must pay for a criminal war.

[Davis_X_Machina]

1. Father G. is spot on, as usual.

I've got my "Support the troops -- bring them HOME" bumpersticker on the van. Too bad I got a cantalope-sized rock through the back window last Thanskgiving. :-(

[n2doc]

2. Quick! Tell Tom Friedman we have found another terrorist supporter

:sarcasm:

That aside, great article. The LA times has another one today, same idea:

http://www.latimes.com/news/opinion/commentary/la-oe-makdisi29jul29,0,5509950.story

Brutality that boomerangs

By Saree Makdisi, a professor of English literature at UCLA, is teaching in London for the summer.


I am angered and sickened by the bombings here in London on July 7, but I am equally angered by the unthinking reactions in the United States and Britain to those disgusting attacks.

The usual self-congratulatory contrast between "our" civilization and "their" barbarism has set the stage for a cycle of moralistic inquiries into the motivations of suicide bombers and the supposed duty of "good" Muslims to restrain "bad" ones.

Few have noticed that suicide bombing is merely a tactic used by those who lack other means of delivering explosives. Fewer still seem to notice that what happened in London is what occurs every time a U.S. or British warplane unloads its bombs on an Iraqi village. (more)

[yorkiemommie1]

3. pat buchanan has been saying the same thing

in his articles.

http://antiwar.com/pat/



........It is the presence of U.S. troops in Islamic lands that is the progenitor of suicide terrorism.

Bush's cure for terrorism is a cause of the epidemic. The doctor is spreading the disease. The longer we stay in Iraq, the greater the number of suicide attacks we can expect. The sooner we get our troops out, the sooner terrorism over there and over here will end. So Pape says the data proves. This is the precise opposite of what George Bush argues and believes.

[jbfam4]

4. thanks for posting this

What a great article.