|
BBV: EAC Panel- Paper advocates outgunned 3 to 1
Received additional information from Susan Marie Weber. Then I called the EAC (202-566-3100) and talked to Brian Whitener. He says the commission picked the panel to give different perspectives- ....right.......
The commission will take papers and asks that they be submitted by 4pm, May 5. I would suggest email with a hard copy follow up to the DC address given below. Address the hard copy with ATT: Testimony Enclosed. Email: Testimony@EAC.gov
I think the commission needs to receive a LOT of input, don't you?
Each panel member will be given 7 minutes to sumarize.
Anyone who can attend to show support for voter verified paper ballots is encouraged to do so. However, it appears that only the 'invited' panel members will be allowed to address the commission.
Information follows including a summary of the panel members position by another person. (Not me or Weber, I'll make my comments in parentheses)- RE
U.S. Election Assistance Commission 1225 New York Ave. NW - Suite 1100 Washington, DC 20005
ELECTION ASSISTANCE COMMISSION Sunshine Act Meeting
DATE AND TIME: Wednesday, May 5, 2004, at 9 a.m.
PLACE: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Headquarters, 1200 Pennsylvania Ave., NW Room 3000, Rachel L. Carson Great Hall Ariel Rios North Building, Washington, DC (Metro Riders: Take the Orange or Blue Line to Federal Triangle Metro Stop).
STATUS: This meeting will be open to the public.
NOTE: Early Arrival: Those attending are advised to arrive early for registration and security check.
PURPOSE: To conduct a public hearing on the present status of computerized electronic voting systems.
The Following Witness Panels Will Be Presented: Technology Panel, Vendor Panel, Election Administrator Panel, Research Panel and Advocacy Organization Panel.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Bryan Whitener, Telephone: (202) 566-3100.
DeForest B. Soaries, Jr., Chairman, U.S. Election Assistance Commission.
-------
U.S. Election Assistance Commission Public Hearing Agenda
(Unless otherwise indicated, the listed witnesses have been confirmed)
Public Hearing on the use Security and Reliability of Electronic Voting System
9:00 - 9:15 Opening remarks by Commission members
9:15 - 9:35 Overview of Direct Recording Electronic (DRE) Voting Kim Brace, President, Election Data Services, Inc.
9: 40 - 10:40 Technology Panel Dr. Avi Rubin, Johns Hopkins University, Information Security Institute Stephen Berger, IEEE Dr. Ted Selker, MIT Dr. Brit Williams, Kennesaw University, Georgia
(I'm not sure about Berger, Selker and Williams defintely against voter verified paper ballots. Selker and Shamos have been the non-paper computer scientists- and about the only ones- that the industry and LWV use for quotes. Selker and Shamos are not security experts)
10:45 - 11:45 Vendor Panel Hart Intercivic Diebold Avante Election Systems and Software Sequoia
(Does it get any more self evident? The ONLY voter verified paper ballot proponent on here is Avante- outgunned 4 to 1. Balanced perspective? Where are Accupoll and TruVote?)
11:45 - 12:30 Break for Lunch
12:45 - 2:00 Election Administrator Panel Kevin Shelly, Secretary of State of California (invited) Kathy Rogers, State Election Director, Georgia Conny McCormack, Los Angles County, CA, County Clerk and Registrar Denise Lamb, Director of Elections, New Mexico
(Shelly is the only one one here and it looks like his direct participation may not be confirmed. The rest speak for themselves)
2:00 - 2:30 Research / Human Interaction Factors Panel Dr. Sharon Laskowski, National Institute of Standards and Technology Study Alice Miller, Executive Director of D.C. Board of Elections (invited) Dana DeBeauvoir, County Clerk, Austin Texas
(I can't speak to this panel. Maybe others have more information)
2:35 - 4:10 Advocacy Organization Panel Wade Henderson, President, Leadership Conference on Civil Rights (invited) Jim Dickson, Vice President for Governmental Affairs American Association of People with Disabilities Kay Maxwell, President League of Women Voters of the U.S. Angela Arboleda, National Council of La Raza Melanie Campbell, Voices of the Electorate (invited) Chellie Pingree, President, Common Cause
(Dickson and Maxwell are against paper. I'm not sure about Henderson or where Common Cause is currently falling on the issue. But if this is supposed to be an advocacy panel, where is Bev? People from TrueMajority? People from TrueVote Maryland? Rush Holt? Bob Graham? Dennis Kucinich?)
4:10 - 4:25 Closing remarks
(Another view of the panels)
Talk about stacking the deck. With the possible exception of the Research panel, I belive the pro-VVPT position is outnumbered by a factor of at least 3 to 1 on every panel in this hearing. Here's my head count for each of the panels:
Technology panel: Anti-VVPT: 3 Pro-VVPT: 1
Vendor panel: Anti-VVPT: 4 Pro-VVPT: 1
Elections official panel: Anti-VVPT: 3 Pro-VVPT: 1
Research/Human Factors panel: I don't where these folks stand Anti-VVPT: ? Pro-VVPT: ? Unknown Position: 3
Advocacy Organization panel: Anti-VVPT: 3 Pro-VVPT: 1 ` Unknown Position: 2
|