But recognition only raises the deeper question:
why, in the face of incontrovertible evidence to the contrary, does Bush persist in this way? How does it help him to continue repeating himself to a nation that increasingly believes he is lying on several fronts? How does his refusal to meet with Cindy Sheehan help him?
There is a two-part answer to this question:
First, as far as Bush is concerned, he is telling the truth; as Madeleine Albright recently said to Columbia Magazine:
"the most serious problem is that George Bush now believes what he says." Like many of my hospitalized patients, Bush has created a vast, detailed but vague delusional system he feels compelled to maintain at all costs. This system helps him manage the terrifying anxiety that threatens to make his already endangered inner world more chaotic.
The second answer is made clear by his reaction to Cindy Sheehan: he believes his lies because he feels his survival depends on it. He cannot help her mourn; he cannot take responsibility for his destructiveness. If he could he would.
His inner need to be right would not just be modified; his entire internal mental structure would be shattered. Psychoanalytic theory suggests that Bush's true enemy is an aspect of himself -- the overwhelming anxiety he works so hard to manage.
For Bush, lying remains a central defense mechanism in managing his fears; he lies foremost to himself, altering his perception of external or internal reality to fulfill his psychic need to maintain order.
His anxiety is so great that he cannot shift his thinking to account for new information -- especially the fact that patriotic families of patriotic soldiers demand that he speak with them.
From
Why Bush Believes His Lies by Justin Frank on August 16, 2005
More at the link:
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/theblog/archive/justin-frank/why-bush-believes-his-lie_5752.htmlWith this as context, I think we have a basis for understanding the following encounter that Bush had with the Maher Family in February, 2005.
This past February, Maher, and his wife, Adeline, met with the President at the Willow Grove Naval Air Station in Warminster, PA. The President was in town to sell his Social Security plan. He made time to meet with the Mahers,
so long as they would follow one ground rule.“When the White House called my wife, they said she wasn’t allowed to tell even my other son or daughter that we were invited to meet the President.
They didn’t want the press to know, and said the President didn’t want the press to know. If it would have leaked out, we would not have had the meeting.” Which is telling. It belies the complaints of those who think the President has somehow politicized the situation regarding those who have died in Iraq.<clip>
“When the President said our son, or any other son would not die in vain, that made me feel real good, because I certainly don’t want this thing to end up the way Vietnam did,
with American vs. American, and I felt really good he made that statement. The man sticks to his word.”
From
The Consoling President by Michael Smerconish on August 16, 2005
Link:
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/theblog/archive/michael-smerconish/the-consoling-president_5757.htmlI regret that Mr & Mrs Maher, after the loss of their son, were then malignantly victimized by Bush.
Yes, Mr Smerconish, the structure of the encounter is truly "telling," but not because of any effort to avoid politicizing the meeting. Bush did not want anyone questioning his version of the story to the Maher's -- not even their other children.
Read, Mr Smerconish, the words Mr Maher and his wife shared with you and critically compare them to what most of the world knew in February of 2005. Most of the world already knew that Bush's illegal war and occupation of Iraq was responsible for the deaths and injuries of our and our allies' soldiers and the deaths, injuries and torture of many Iraqi citizens. In fact, millions new it to be illegal and criminal before he launched the invasion on March 19, 2003.
Bush has constantly set American against American and the manner in which you relate your story only furthers Bush's divisive agenda.
Just how disconnected was Bush when he met the Maher's -- do a Google search on 'last throes'; 'insurgency failing'; ... just more lies, more propaganda, and he held a super-secret session with grieving parents so he could lie some more, and not have anyone question him.
Just how disconnected does Bush remain ...
How bad is the situation there? Barham Salih, Iraq’s minister of planning and development, tried to look at the bright side of things by saying, “We are failing to reach compromises. But we are not killing each other.” []bYou know things are in trouble when the good news is that the Founding Fathers of the New Iraq are not blowing each other to bits.
Too bad the same cannot be said for the insurgents targeting our troops and ordinary Iraqis.
Yes, Cindy Sheehan is merely a symbol of the Iraq debacle. But presidents are symbols too.
And symbols matter -- especially in a time of war. And projecting an image of total disconnection to what is going on in Iraq -- and the pain it is causing here at home, as well as the precious resources it is consuming -- is a very disturbing message for Bush to be sending.<clip>
The president also let us know that it’s important for him
“to keep a balanced life”. Well, I’m all for balance -- we Greeks invented it.
But it seems the presidential equilibrium has gone way out of whack. To regain his footing he needs to re-connect to the crisis in Iraq, give Cindy Sheehan a few minutes of his time, and get the hell out of Crawford.
Show us you’re willing to make a sacrifice in a time of war, Mr. President -- even if that just means cutting your vacation a little short. Those of us who are mindful of what is really going on around us will appreciate the crispness of that decision.
From
The War Comes to Crawford, The President Disconnects by Arianna Huffington on August 16, 2005
Link:
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/theblog/archive/arianna-huffington/the-war-comes-to-crawford_5756.html The problem is, as Justin Frank notes,
"Taking responsibility has always been hard for George W. Bush. And taking responsibility for inflicting harm on others, a major step in the development of maturity, is a step President Bush has yet to make. Instead, he persists in lying to himself, surrounding himself with people who agree with him. And now he is not safe even inside his own closed circle."Only someone who starts an illegal war could be behaving as Bush currently is -- five weeks vacation.
Only someone who starts an illegal war could know that a memorial to those who have died has been destroyed, and not condemn it.
Only someone who authorizes torture could talk about keeping a 'balanced life' while riding a bicycle and not get the cold, heartless cruel irony of his actions and his words.
We need regime change, here -- now.
Peace.