But to back up, I didn't include the link to Clark's full speech:
http://clark04.com/speeches/008Gentleman, we are all realists here and recognize the almost universal dominance of Machiavellian logic underlying the noble platitudes of the propaganda espoused. Misters Bunter and Magistrate, you are extremely intelligent and I know you know this despite the idealisms you use to admonish me for my cynicism.
I think the quote from Tony Blair as cited by Clark is very telling. The issue of NATO and UN action (and, conversely, inaction) was and remains controversial because of the values demonstrated. NATO has been accused of representing the sum of the corporate interests that dominate each of the member countries.
The values displayed have been described as racist for the lack of intervention in, for instance, Rwanda. The UN was excoriated for intentionally avoiding the use of the word 'genocide' which would mandate a response.
I remember accusations of racism levied against NATO in '99 when it was said that the only reason NATO took any action in the Balkans was because white Europeans were involved and, most importantly, the CREDIBILITY OF NATO required doing something. Rather like a cop who has to act on a traffic violation to maintain law and order because many people are watching. And the US has routinely gone after easy targets such as Libya or Panama or Granada or Iraq as a show of force to underscore the implied threat of willingness to deploy US might, otherwise known as STATE-SPONSORED TERRORISM. Ah, spreading values by example. Too true. Holocaust, genocide, apartheid, war crimes-this is the US's history against people of color, foreign and domestic. Spreading values by example indeed.
Gentleman, since we are frequently gathered to discuss this arena of morality, I'd like to share my personal involvement with war in the Balkans and the atrocities there. I recall recent posts amongst you wondering how people could be so uninvolved or in denial of terrible events that they aren't moved to response. Well...
I'm 42 years old. When I was 6, a friend showed me his father's photos of liberating the Nazi's concentration camps. I saw skeletal bodies stacked like cord wood. I've known my species was dangerous ever since. I marched against Vietnam in '68 when I was 7 years old. I saw pictures of VC heads displayed as trophies by US GIs when I was 10 and read first hand accounts of hand-to-hand combat by 'cherry' GIs.
During the NATO bombing of Kosovo in April '99, I was taking a jazz trio around Italy. I was in Pescara on the east coast of the Adriatic, a mere 300 miles from the atrocities. I could hardly concentrate on my job knowing I was but a few hours from ethnic cleansing and camps that smacked of Nazi-ism. Refugees from the war-torn areas were flooding into Italy and jamming the trains we were traveling on. Then...
On May 8 '99, I spent all day doing sound for a show with Vedran Smailovic, The Cellist of Sarajevo. "The man who shook his cello in the face of bombs, death, and ruin and defied them all."
>article excerpt<
"This is the true story of an ordinary man who lived in Sarajevo - a city under siege.On 27th May 1992, Vedran Smailovic, principal cellist of the Sarajevo Opera Orchestra, stood athis window looking at a long line of hungry men, women, and children standing outside a bakery. As he looked at his starving friends and neighbors, a mortar landed among them, killing 22. Mr Smailovic ran to help the survivors. When the makeshift ambulances arrived, having to dodge constant sniper fire on the roads, Mr Smailovic helped load in his friends,and then watched as they began the perilous journey back to the hospital. Left alone at the site of destruction, Mr Smailovic realized he had to do something more. But he wasn’t a soldier or a surgeon: what could a cellist possibly do to help in this situation? The next day at the precise hour of the shelling, Mr Smailovic walked to the site of the massacre and made his stand. His weapon? A cello. His ammunition? Music. Dressed in his formal tuxedo and seated on a stool in the crater left by the shell, Vedran Smailovic played Albinoni’s lugubrious Adagio in G minor, which ironically had been found in pieces in the rubble of Dresden, Germany, after WW II. Everyday at exactly 4 pm for a total of 22 days– one to honor each of his dead friends – the Cellist of Sarajevo played, while bullets flew around him. Soon his story was circling the globe and drawing the world’s attention to the atrocities in Sarajevo."
The concert I worked on also had readings of people's accounts of rape and betrayal by their long-time neighbors. I weep just remembering this day I spent with Vedran Smailovic. So understand that I have very deep personal feelings about the situation and a revulsion for injustice and atrocities. Thought you might be interested.