Whose rendition of "Imagine" is better, Lennon's or Madonna's?

[UrbScotty]

Poll question: Whose rendition of "Imagine" is better, Lennon's or Madonna's?

Goodness, I thought they were trying to ENCOURAGE people to help the cause.

[catbert836]

1. Madonna can't sing

She comes nowhere near a "rendition" of Lennon's masterwork.

[DODI]

2. All I could ask was "Why?"

[cruadin]

3. I'm sorry, I couldn't hear you. I had to go clean my ears...

out with Drano after hearing Madonna do, whatever it is she does with her voice, to "Imagine."

[7th_Sephiroth]

4. i heard this scary-assed version of imagine

i think it was done by the cure or something

[smiley_glad_hands]

8. A Perfect Circle

http://promo.virginrecords.net/artists/a_perfect_circle/imagine_clickable/player/

[smiley_glad_hands]

9. Dupe

http://promo.virginrecords.net/artists/a_perfect_circle/imagine_clickable/player/

[smiley_glad_hands]

11. Dupe

http://promo.virginrecords.net/artists/a_perfect_circle/imagine_clickable/player/

[fluffernutter]

5. lol, great poll.

[Zensea]

6. I was getting ready to flame you

until I saw the actual poll

[smiley_glad_hands]

7. APC eom

http://promo.virginrecords.net/artists/a_perfect_circle/imagine_clickable/player/

[BBradley]

10. I agree

[DemBones DemBones]

12. Good to get that settled!

:7

[nytemare]

13. It was for a good cause, and my vote goes to Lennon

The song is about 1/2 octave to low for her voice. They should have done it in another key. Even then, Imagine by Lennon is about the best rock song ever, and nobody will do a better job than Lennon.

[Cooper]

14. i'm sorry, but imagine sucks.

most over-rated song in history.

i love seeing the "all one" bumper stickers. it's like saying "my entire political philosophy is summed up in a pop song."

[LeftPeopleFinishFirst]

15. I hate it when people rape classics...

nt

[AuntiBush]

16. I had a tough time deciding

then I thought, oh, what the hey. Thanks for the :)

[UrbScotty]

18. Yeah

;-)

[tyedyeto]

17. I voted for the turquoise version..

Haven't been watching the concert tonight.

Madonna singing John Lennon??????? just about breaks the heart.

[B Calm]

21. Had to go with the Blue one for political reasons only!

[B Calm]

19. Who's MaDonna?

[rockedthevoteinMA]

20. I had to mute it... ugh n/t

[Magrittes Pipe]

22. Thee Mighty Caesars

"All right, all right, that enough o' that shit!"