Which "American Idol" contestant is going home tonight?

[MissMillie]

Poll question: Which "American Idol" contestant is going home tonight?

Mandissa is a favorite of mine, but I don't think her song choice won her any points last night. (Not that I didn't enjoy it, but I get the feeling that a lot of people just went "huh?")

My favorite performance of the evening was Paris.

Taylor did well. I was not at all impressed with Ace, Bucky or Katharine.


What do you think? Who is going HOME?

[Squatch]

1. I think Chris took an uneccessary risk with that Creed song.

That particular song does not have very good mass appeal.

[AllegroRondo]

4. Many other Creed songs he could have done

I have to agree with Simon this week, Chris is coming across as too one-dimensional.

[azmouse]

2. I think Bucky will go home this week.

Next week Ace should go. He's just awful!

[begin_within]

3. I am tired of Chris. He's good at what he does, but that's all he can do.

[mvd]

22. A couple times he showed promise

But my worst fear came true when he actually did a CREED song. And called the band a favorite of his. :scared:

[snacker]

5. I didn't think any of them did well last night...

especially compared to last week when they were all great.

[azmouse]

9. I wonder how much influence Barry Manilow had

on how good the contestants sounded last week? He really seemed to help them find the right key and kicked up the songs a bit for them.

[begin_within]

18. Manilow gave all of them a needed shot in the arm of professionalism.

This week they all sank back down to their amateur levels like so many collapsed souffles.

[Maine-ah]

6. Kellie really sucked.

if you haven't seen this yet you should check it out.

www.votefortheworst.com

[mvd]

21. It was embarrassing

And what was with the cheesy wink she did? It's ok to have fun in a song, but it was like she wasn't serious at all about her song.

[RevolutionaryActs]

7. I love Taylor, and Chris and Bucky.

Please don't send Bucky home. :cry: Send Lisa... or Ace. Oh yes, please send Ace. :puke:

[mvd]

24. Yea, another Bucky supporter

I'm not alone here. I thought Bucky had a solid performance last night. Sounded a bit like Tracy Lawrence on the song IMO.

[RevolutionaryActs]

26. I loved him last night.

I think he's really good. I hope he stays. :(

[mvd]

28. Sending good vibes to him right now

:hi:

[npincus]

8. Ace is terrible.. his looks have carried him this far.

He also has a sort of terrified expression when he sings- no charisma.

I love Paris (in the springtime- tee hee) and Taylor.

[azmouse]

10. I don't think he's even all that good looking!

blech...:puke:

[npincus]

12. yeah- he's not my type. But I can see how others might like him.

Just like last year's Constantine Maroulis... I did not get his appeal at all. i thought he was a poser and way over-rated.

Now, Taylor is more appealing to me. I like tall, big guys... a little chub doesn't bother me at all.

[MissMillie]

13. hear hear!

Real people with real bodies....

[azmouse]

15. Constantine had a butt-chin. LOL

I like Taylor too! He looks like he'd be a lot of fun to be around.

[Mike Daniels]

11. I loved Simon's reaction when Paula was lusting after Ace's scar

You could practically see all color drain from face and his expression freeze. I've never seen anyone lunge into a conversation as fast as Simon did at that moment.

[npincus]

14. I think Paula is a loose (and lustful) cannon!

After her (alleged) affair with a contestant last year, you'd think she'd be more careful... I am sure the producers have her under heavy surveillance.

[azmouse]

16. I heard the producers thought of firing Paula a few weeks ago

and replacing her with Jessica Simpson or Brittany Spears! Unbelieveable!!

[npincus]

17. I hope they keep her around.

Don't mess with success! As for the bimbos, lets see if their fame holds up for 2 decades.

[beyurslf]

25. I just want her to come on one night without being lit to the max.

She looks stoned off her ass every night anymore.

[beyurslf]

19. Paris was the only truly good performance last night.

Somany to choose from to go home. Buckey, Ace, and Kelli all need ot leave but we can only choose one. I go with Buckey.

[mvd]

20. It might be Lisa

Personally, I think there were only two bad performances last night - Kellie's and Chris's. There were a few mediocre ones. I thought Ace, Katharine, Mandisa, Paris, and Taylor were good. It was clearly Mandisa's worst song choice, but she makes most everything worth doing. Best of the night was Taylor - just a smidgen better than Paris.

[bigwillq]

23. I hope Chris stays

he's cute. :evilgrin:

[RevolutionaryActs]

27. Uh.. duh!

:9

[bigwillq]

29. Reminds me a bit of Vin Diesel!

YUMMY! :evilgrin:

[RevolutionaryActs]

31. Oh yes..... Mmm Vin...

Is it getting a little hot in here? :o

[bigwillq]

32. Stop it!

No more posting hot pics. You're making me, err..,....blush! :blush:

[RevolutionaryActs]

33. Bwhahahahaa!

What about this hottie? Can I post this pic?

;) :loveya:

[bigwillq]

34. LOL!

Now I am really blushing over you're silliness of posting my pic! :blush:

[RevolutionaryActs]

36. What's silly?

It's true. Hottie. :loveya:

[bigwillq]

37. Silly

because I can't believe you just posted my pic in your post.
:)

Thank you for the lovely compliment! :hug:

[mvd]

30. I'm the same way with Katharine

I love her distinctive voice, and thought she showed her range last night (deserved a better song.) But I have a crush on her, and that's another reason I don't want her to leave..

[bigwillq]

35. It's funny how we get attached

to people in that way. They're a freaking contestant on a game show and we don't want them to leave because we "like them"! LOL! :hi:

[L A Woman]

38. I voted for Lisa..or against her, I mean.

she isn't memorable at all. I hope Chris or Elliot wins the whole thing. And I hope Paula keeps drinking before the show. :-)