American Idol tonight!!

[MsKandice01]

My addiction to this show has reached new heights. It's sickening. I'm sitting here counting down the hours until it starts...which really sucks because I'm on the West Coast and I've still got 4 hours left to go.

Vote for Elliott!!!!

[fleabert]

1. VOTE FOR CHRIS!

me too, I am really addicted. I will have to wait longer, I am recording it and watching even later tonight! :grr:

[snacker]

4. Chris is my favorite. n/t

[distantearlywarning]

2. I am a closet Idol fan too.

It's embarrassing. I can't admit that I watch it to anyone I know, and I have found myself more than once making up another excuse for why I can't do anything on Tuesday nights.

I must disagree with you on the Elliott thing, though. I don't like him. I'm rooting for Paris Bennett and Katherine McPhee.

[Catfight]

7. mcphee is up, in a tight busty yellow long dress that looks worse than

my big Gap terry cloth bathrobe. She's not doing it for me tonight, too canned and too standard really. Here's what simon had to say, Randy always says the same Randy boring shit (he didn't like it), Paula will like it, Simon's the only real one: Simon says she's not as good as Whitney, he didn't like the song. It sucked.


Her cleavage won't win votes tonight....

[Catchawave]

3. Isn't it Andrea Bocelli/love song night ?

Thanks for the reminder :hi:

[Catfight]

5. watching now...tonight is going to suck...love ballads? I'll keep you

posted. Right now, they are going through their song choices with that dude who is way over rated, the yanni of love songs...anyone endorsed by dr. phil is way over rated. LOL

[Beaverhausen]

6. Of course it will suck - why should tonight be any different?

:banghead: :banghead: :banghead: :banghead:

[Catfight]

8. it will suck more because it's Bocelli night..love songs...someone

should sing, "You Outta Know," now that's a love song!

[babylonsister]

11. Andrea Bocelli, the opera singer?

I love his voice and I'm not even into opera.

[Catchawave]

28. Yes, he'll sing *live* tommorrow night, he's just in the

rehearsal clips tonight :D

[babylonsister]

9. I LOVE Eliot! He rocked the house!

He has evolved, and I've always loved his voice!

[Catfight]

10. yeah, and he looks so much better with his little hair doo. I dig him.

[Catfight]

12. I can't stand pickler, she reminds me of brittney, a high school drop

out that never read a book in her life. Little girls will look up to her and want to be like her and that's the shame of it all.

[Catfight]

13. She's TERRIBLE, it hurts my ears, I suspect she's next to be voted off.

[Catfight]

15. Paris is slaughtering "memories," why would anyone attempt a

well known Barbara Streisand song? Is she insane? Make it stop!

[LostinVA]

17. Too young, don't like how she pronounces stuff, and she annoys me

At least The Pick knows when she screws up...

Katherine and Elliot have been the best tonight... although poor Elliott always bores me... however, I'd buy a cd of his in a sec, just not a concert ticket. Katherine was better than the judges said... imo.

[babylonsister]

23. I agree! I love Eliot, but I thought Katherine was great, too. nt

[Maddy McCall]

18. What did she sing?

Can't stand her, either. She prides herself in her stupidity.

[babylonsister]

20. Unchained Melody, if you can believe that.

I was afraid she'd ruin it for me, but she was so far beyond bad, it's won't make a blip. :)

[Maddy McCall]

24. no No NO!

She was a fool to do Unchained Melody.

[babylonsister]

26. She proved she's not good enough to be there. She was wooden,

sang it w/o emotion. That's no way to treat that song!

[Catfight]

21. The song from "Ghost," I forget already. Her hair whoop was crazy too.

[fortyfeetunder]

40. Kellie was horrible last week and not in the bottom three

I bet Paris will be voted off before Kellie will...Kellie is a unidimensional country singer, which is good for country but far from being Idol material....

[Mike Daniels]

45. Pickler should have been gone weeks ago.

I have a feeling that a significant part of her voting base are hormonally overloaded teenage guys who caught site of her prom dress photo and her stage humping routine during Queen week.

When I saw Katherine displaying her talents last night I figured it was a grab for that part of Kellie's base. Sort of..."if I have to bare flesh to get push this no-talent fake bimbo to the bottom rung so be it."

[AtomicKitten]

42. I started a huge Taylor Hicks fan

and still am, but Elliott has an unbelievable voice. At first, most thought he was fugly, but he's such a mellow, nice guy, and his voice is superb, so he's sorta becoming kinda cute.

[LostinVA]

14. Crosspost: "A Song for You " is a Carpenters' song, dammit!

Just like "Superstar." (although it's also okay to call it a Bette Midler song). Karen Carpenter is the one who made all these songs well known but does she get the credit? One of the top female voices ever? NO.

Drives me bonkers.

[Catfight]

19. Awe, LostinVA, don't go bonkers! You know, if mama cass gave

Karen that sandwich, they might both be alive today.

[LostinVA]

27. That was soooo bad!

The Cass thing is an urban legend btw!

[babylonsister]

22. Was this the Donny Hathaway one? I remember

Joe Cocker singing it!

[qanda]

31. I just watched the Karen Carpenter Movie tonight

It's amazing how many songs she made famous.

[LostinVA]

33. The one with Cynthia Gibb? That was good

What was that on?

[qanda]

34. It was on Encore

I just happened to catch it while channel surfing. My dog died today and Karen's beautiful voice and music was perfect to help me through this tough day.

On Edit: I just read your post to me in the other thread. Thank you so much and thank your kitties also-- DU is the best!

[LostinVA]

41. Cyber hugs

[Maddy McCall]

16. Taylor.

Love him. He's going to win. (I hope.)

[Catfight]

25. Not GreyCharles best tonight, but he'll get through. nt

[babylonsister]

29. I love Eliot, but Chris also rocked tonight. Phew. nt

[LostinVA]

30. Chris was GOOD... on a song I don't like

I'd buy his cd tomorrow...

My Bearded Growly Bear Bo is a much better performer, but my Little Grungy Cueball is a way better singer...

[qanda]

32. I thought he was good too

I usually don't like his voice, but I thought that was really good. I also loved Elliott-- he has a wonderful voice!

[blue neen]

35. Chris had the best performance of the night.

He is actually improving every week. Some of these performers do not seem to be evolving.

I saw upthread that your doggie passed away today. That hurts. I'm sorry.

[grasswire]

36. on MSNBC news, it was said that Pickler stuffed the ballot box

What's that about? They said it is a scandal.

[Catchawave]

37. Vote for the Worst ?

http://votefortheworst.com/ai5.html

[AtomicKitten]

43. I hope redneck America cuts her loose from the herd.

she is awful.

[bullwinkle428]

38. Okay, I'm calling out bigwillq's ass out right now!! Said Elliott

deserved to leave last week! I want to see him try to justify dropping Elliott in favor of keeping Pickler around this week! :evilgrin:

[mvd]

39. Missed the show tonight

Had to. Had company over. It was worth missing Idol, as I made a new friend with things in common. She's busy at grad school now, but I hope to get to know her more.

Anyway, I voted for Katharine only as she's my favorite - and a constant. It would be hard to top her performance from last week, though.

[southernleftylady]

44. Chris is the best hands down!

[MissMillie]

46. I missed the first 3 performances

Of the 3 I saw, Chris won hands down.

I voted for Paris 'cause I think she's great and I'm not ready to see her leave.

[bigwillq]

47. Chris is my American Idol!

He's so darn cute and he gave a wonderful performance last night. :bounce:


I hope it's Chris and Katherine in the final.

[bullwinkle428]

48. Distant second to Elliott, but a nice performance nonetheless.

I wouldn't mind seeing him up against Elliott in the finals, though... :evilgrin:

[bigwillq]

49. See, I just don't like Elliott

I still think besides Pickler, he is the weakest.

Just my opinion though. I am just never impressed with him.

[Ravenseye]

50. I agree

Elliot has grown on me, but just not enough at this point. He's convinced me that he belongs in the final 12, but that's it. He's bland. He seems like a nice guy, but otherwise when he sings it's just...I don't know...nothing. He doesn't do it for me, and I think many other people.