Seems they are open to all ideas, including a national sales tax, but feel that the options for radical overhaul are limited
http://www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/nation/la-na-tax17feb17,1,7129932.story?coll=la-headlines-nation Commission Begins Review of the Tax Code
But the presidential panel indicates it may modify, rather than replace, the system.
By Warren Vieth
Times Staff Writer
February 17, 2005
WASHINGTON — A presidential commission on Wednesday launched what it promised would be a top-to-bottom review of the U.S. tax code, but acknowledged that it might be wiser to modify the existing income tax than to replace it.
Members of the President's Advisory Panel on Federal Tax Reform said all options were on the table, including proposals to replace personal and corporate income taxes with variations on a national sales tax.<snip>
Former Sen. John B. Breaux (D-La.), the panel's vice chairman, said that Bush had directed the commission to draft at least one proposal that would retain the current income tax, preserve incentives for homeownership and charitable contributions, assume that Congress would make all of Bush's previous tax cuts permanent and make sure any additional changes neither raised nor lowered overall tax collections.
In addition, Breaux said, the president told the commission to complete its work in less than six months. "It's an extraordinarily difficult task," he said.
A former Internal Revenue Service commissioner, Fred T. Goldberg Jr., told the commission that Bush's preconditions appeared to rule out the possibility of scrapping the income tax and replacing it with another form of taxation.
<snip>
Among the possibilities they mentioned: supplementing the income tax with a European-style value-added tax, which is similar to a sales levy but is imposed at every level of production; and scaling back or eliminating the alternative minimum tax, which is imposed on affluent taxpayers who claim big deductions.<snip>