Patrick Lang: Dennis Ross and the "Jewish People Planning Institute"

[laststeamtrain]

Dennis Ross and the "Jewish People Planning Institute"

"A think tank founded recently by The Jewish Agency. The Jewish People Policy Planning Institute was established in 2002 by the Jewish Agency for Israel to be an independent professional policy planning think tank entrusted with the mission of promoting the identity, culture, prosperity, and continuity of the Jewish People. Every year, leaders of the Jewish world including such distinguished personalities as Dennis Ross, Shimon Peres, Natan Sharansky, Malcolm Hoenlein, Tzipi Livni, participate in JPPPI’s conferences and meetings that forecast the Jewish condition. The Institute conducts meetings, publishes reports and position papers, and produce contingency plans that help shape the future course of the global Jewish community." ...http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jewish_Agency

This is undoubtedly a laudable institution, but is it an institution that should be the "day job" of the US presidential envoy to and for Iran? Should we be surprised if Muslims do not think Dennis Ross an unbiased American negotiator?

Dennis Ross is the head of this group and a former head and present counselor of the "Washington Institute for Near East Policy." (WINEP) For those who know not, WINEP is one of a galaxy of Washington groups that exist within the orbit of AIPAC, the Zionist lobby. There are others; the "Jewish Institute for National Security," (JINSA), "Business Executives for National Security" (BENS), etc.

Ross served as a presidential envoy in the Clinton Administration negotiations with the Palestinians. His role in the catastrophic failure of the Camp David 2 talks has yet to be fully appreciated by the general public. In essence, he brought together Ehud Barak (Israeli PM) and Yasser Arafat (PLO chief) in an isolated location for the purpose of "pressure cooker" negotiations with the Palestinians to forge a final, end state solution for the Palestine problem. This process failed when the Palestinians could not or would not carry the negotiations into areas for which they felt that they had no prior agreement among the various Arab governments that had met at Rabat on the subject. What Ross did not comprehend or accept before Camp David 2 was that the Palestinian delegation did not have a "blank check" to negotiate outside the Arab consensus and that the enforced isolation at Camp David kept them from the possibility of achieving a new consensus while the talks were underway. Failure inevitably ensued and the situation has continued to deteriorate ever since.

As I have written before, the assumption that Iran is an implacable enemy of the United States, and a country that is not accessible by reason on the basis of its national interest is a self fulfilling policy position.

If Dennis Ross is made the US special envoy to Iran there is every reason to believe from his prior statements and actions that he will proceed on the basis of that flawed assumption. ...http://turcopolier.typepad.com/sic_semper_tyrannis/2009/01/dennis-ross-and-the-jewish-people-planning-institute.html
*

People might remember Lang from from the "CIA leak hearings"; the basement hearings...http://www.talkleft.com/story/2005/07/22/454/83791

I think he could be called an 'old hand' at Middle East policy stuff with an informed opinion worth hearing on Mr. Ross.
*

[ikojo]

1. I can almost guarantee that ONLY one perspective

on Israel will be considered at the Jewish People Policy Planning Institute, and that will be the one of perpetual war and ultra nationalism.

They wanna know why many Jews don't affiliate: how about the fact many don't feel welcomed at a synagogue or in Jewish organizations unless they toe the establishment line.

[Duckhunter935]

2. I think that could apply to both sides