Israel: End Ban on Human Rights Monitors

[Scurrilous]

IDF Denies Human Rights Watch, B’Tselem Access to Gaza

<snip>

(Jerusalem, February 22, 2009) – Israel continues to obstruct independent investigations into allegations of laws of war violations by the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) and Hamas military forces in Gaza by preventing independent human rights monitors from entering Gaza, Human Rights Watch and B’Tselem said today. After submitting applications for permission to enter via the Erez crossing in January 2009, the groups faced continued delays from the IDF unit reviewing the applications. In February, the IDF told Human Rights Watch that it had rejected its application. The Israeli military denied B’Tselem's first request to enter Gaza and has failed to respond to a second.

“Israel’s refusal to allow human rights groups access to Gaza raises a strong suspicion that there are things it doesn’t want us to see or the world to know about its military operation there,” said Sarah Leah Whitson, Middle East director at Human Rights Watch. “If Israel has nothing to hide, why is it refusing to allow us in?”

Human Rights Watch requested permission to enter Gaza on January 5. After weeks of delay, the IDF rejected the application on February 9, on the grounds that Human Rights Watch “was not registered with the Ministry of Social Affairs.” On all previous occasions, including several times in 2008, Israeli authorities permitted Human Rights Watch staff to enter and leave Gaza via the Erez crossing. The IDF never previously suggested such a requirement for access to Gaza, and Human Rights Watch is not aware of any such Israeli law or regulation. The IDF has not responded to Human Rights Watch’s requests for clarification.

Israel does not allow Jewish citizens of Israel, other than security forces, to enter Gaza on the grounds that their security would be at risk. B’Tselem, the Israeli Information Center for Human Rights in the Occupied Territories, on January 20 requested permission from the IDF to allow the organization’s fieldwork director (a Palestinian citizen of Israel) to enter Gaza. The IDF refused the request nine days later. B’Tselem submitted an additional request on January 29 for entry for three staff members and an international consultant. The Israeli military has not responded to this request.

more

[oberliner]

1. Many human rights groups operate in Gaza

Just not any Israeli ones.

[Idealism]

2. Thus a problem with credibility

You have certain members on here that refuse to believe PCHR or other Palestinian groups because they are deemed to have an agenda, which obviously they do, but when the an equally slanted Israeli organization puts out a statement, it becomes paraded around as gospel truth.

The fact is people believe Israeli media over Palestinian media.

[oberliner]

3. B'Tselem is usually treated similarly to PCHR

At least from what I've read.

[Idealism]

4. In this regard it seems not

Otherwise they would be inside Gaza

[oberliner]

5. I meant in terms of how seriously they are taken by the international community

Israel can dictate whether or not Israelis can enter Gaza but they have no jurisdiction within Gaza itself.

[Idealism]

6. I would say B'Tselem is taken more seriously than PCHR

At least, I view B'Tselem is one of the most credible human rights groups in the Middle-East. They are up there with Amnesty and HRW, where PCHR (to me) is below their caliber.