Egypt Pulls the Plug on a Failed U.S.-Israeli Gaza Strategy

[Purveyor]

Tony Karon Thursday, May 26, 2011 at 10:03 pm

It might have been easy, amid the raucous cheering at Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's Capitol Hill pep rally on Tuesday, for Israelis to ignore President Obama's earlier warning of a gathering storm on Israel's horizon. But Wednesday's announcement that Egypt plans, on Saturday, to effectively end the siege of Gaza by permanently opening the Rafah border crossing brought home the harsh truth of Israel's increasingly isolated position. (Obama, the same day, got a non-commital response from Prime Minister David Cameron in London when urging Britain to join the U.S. in opposing a September U.N. vote recognizing Palestinian statehood.)

Obama, in his Sunday speech at AIPAC, had warned Israel that the wave of democracy reshaping the Arab world meant that that "a just and lasting peace can no longer be forged with one or two Arab leaders... millions of Arab citizens have to see that peace is possible for that peace to be sustained." While the U.S. would stand by Israel unconditionally, Obama warned that "the march to isolate Israel internationally -- and the impulse of the Palestinians to abandon negotiations –- will continue to gain momentum in the absence of a credible peace process and alternative. And for us to have leverage with the Palestinians, to have leverage with the Arab States and with the international community, the basis for negotiations has to hold out the prospect of success."

The "basis for negotiations" offered by Netanyahu on Tuesday won't reverse the growing Arab and European skepticism of the prospects for success in U.S.-led negotiations. Wednesday's Egyptian announcement on Gaza seemed to underscore Obama's point. Gone is President Hosni Mubarak, whose own animus towards Hamas (the offspring of his domestic nemesis, the Muslim Brotherhood) made him an enthusiastic backer of the U.S.-Israel strategy on Gaza. Mubarak, as Obama implied, never represented the will of his people, and even before they elect a government certain to be tougher on Israel, an interim military leadership more heedful of public sentiment made clear it could no longer sustain the blockade.

But the siege strategy had failed long before this week. Its purpose had been not simply to prevent arms from entering the territory, but to topple Hamas. And it effectively achieved neither. From the moment the Islamist movement won the Palestinian legislative elections in January 2006, Israel — with the support of the U.S. — began to restrict Gaza's economic lifeline to the outside world. And after Hamas expelled security forces loyal to Fatah in a violent power struggle in 2007, Israel tightened the noose. The plan was to deprive Gazans of many basic commodities — not starving them, but "putting them on a diet" in the memorably callous explanation offered by a senior Israeli official -- in hopes that imposing a twilight existence on the territory would turn the civilian population against Hamas. Banned items ranged from basic construction materials to coriander, sage, ginger, A4 paper, notebooks, toys, pens and pencils, seeds and nuts, livestock, fishing nets and a host of other commodities with no plausible military use.

MORE...

http://globalspin.blogs.time.com/2011/05/26/egypt-pulls-the-plug-on-a-failed-u-s-israeli-gaza-strategy/

[oberliner]

1. It's the Rootless Cosmopolitan - Tony Karon!

"Global Spin" indeed.

[aquart]

2. Since the Rafah gate opens tomorrow, what difference does it make

what Israel bans? Buy it in Egypt.

And what day in the last 63 years has there NOT been a "storm gathering on Israel's horizon"? Lotta fuss for a postage stamp without oil.

BTW, banning coriander from people actively trying to kill you is a damned gentle revenge.