|
But they're calling it "tax reform" instead of "raising taxes." And it's going to be a lower/middle class tax increase instead of an increase in the marginal rates.
The two proposals they're throwing up as trial balloons are:
1) Eliminate the pre-tax nature of health insurance premiums paid by employees.
2) Eliminate the deduction for state income taxes.
No idea if either of these will pass, but if they pass the first one, the current health care "crisis" in this country will become a serious crisis. Some idiot on CNBC was saying this morning that whether or not the premium paid by the employee (the employee part of the total premium) is pre-tax or after-tax, people will choose health insurance over cash. Unfortunately, her statement shows a total lack of understanding of the nature of GROUP insurance. Why would employers bother with offering health insurance if there is no tax benefit to their employees (other than the altruistic nature of certains businesses).
Let's see, I'm an employer, I get a deduction whether I pay you a salary or contribute to your health insurance premium (same deduction -- general expense). (If I'm wrong on this point, any accountants out there, let me know.) Because my employees get a tax break on their portion, I offer them insurance. This costs me money in terms of human resources personnel, consulting expenses, etc. Now, no more tax break for my employees. So the $4,000 I was spending and the $2,000 they were spending on family coverage is all treated the same -- I as the employer get a $6,000 deduction since $4,000 is a general expense and the $2,000 is a salary expense, and the member gets taxed on the $2,000 the same as regular income. So there's less of an incentive for employers to continue to offer medical benefits as part of their employee benefits and more incentive for them just to bump everyone's salary by the $4,000 they were paying anyway.
Great, you say, more money for me. Well, if you're a 25 year old male, you're right. You can go buy health insurance cheaper than the extra money you got in your paycheck. If you're a 55 year old male with two teenage children, you're screwed. On the open market, $6,000 is not going to buy you the same insurance you were getting through your employer. And if you have diabetes and congestive heart failure -- forget about it. If you can even get insurance, it will cost you a lot more than the extra money you get in your paycheck.
The good news is the health insurance companies know this, and they form a very powerful lobby, so this is not likely to happen any time soon. But if it does, and employers bail on providing health insurance since it's no longer worth the headache, the ranks of the uninsured will increase, and we will have a true health care crisis in this country.
Think about this when you hear the proposal floated, and what it will do to lower income people who have health problems.
As for eliminating the state income tax deduction, that's a direct hit on your average middle class family with a mortgage. A family making $60,000 and paying $3,000 in state income tax would be hit with approximately a $750 - $1,000 tax increase. Thanks for that wonderful idea!
I welcome any comments/rebukes!
|