Iraq Consitution will be better or worse than Hitler's Weimar Republic

[papau]

Poll question: Iraq Consitution will be better or worse than Hitler's Weimar Republic

The Weimar Republic consitution was said to be a liberal western democracy with minority rights protected - and that was the law under which Hitler was elected.

Today we are told that we fight in Iraq to prevent a dictatorship by one religion with minority/women rights sharply reduced as in Iran.

Yesterday a journalist exposed the fact that "safe and secure" Basra in southern Iraq is being run by the thug mobs of the religious leadership, who kill any who disagree with them - as to disagree is to disrespect the religious leadership.

So, - Monday's Constitution - what will it look like?

[tx_dem41]

1. What Iraqi Constitution are you talking about?

i.e. I voted for "There will be no Iraq Constitution tomorrow".

[Totally Committed]

2. No matter when the "Constitution" comes,

and no matter what the components or beneficiaries, Women will lose a majority of the rights they held in a secular Iraq.

[Name removed]

3. Deleted message

Message removed by moderator. Click here to review the message board rules.

[IndianaGreen]

4. Civil war will be triggered by the new constitution

When Iraqis speak of federalism they don't mean it in the American sense. Iraqi federalism means that the Shias in the Basra region keep all the oil profits to themselves, while the Kurds in Mosul do the same. The Sunnis, and the Iraqis in the poor provinces, get nothing! No oil money, period!

How long before the poor rise in opposition to their new masters?

[Yupster]

5. I thought that I had read that

they had reached agreement on the oil sharing percentages already.

[IndianaGreen]

6. That's not what MSM is reporting today

Women will lose no matter what the final draft says.

Sunni negotiator: 'We don’t accept federalism'

On Saturday, Talabani predicted a draft constitution will be ready by Monday’s deadline, and Othman said the draft would be presented to parliament with or without Sunni approval.

U.S. Ambassador Zalmay Khalilzad and U.N. envoy Ashraf Qazi met separately with Sunni leaders Saturday but failed to persuade them to accept a federal system.

“We will not be subdued and will continue to cling to our stance,” Sunni negotiator Kamal Hamdoun said Saturday. “We don’t accept federalism ... We don’t want federalism. We are confident that federalism means division and federalism cannot be approved at this time.”

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/8931395/

[IndianaGreen]

7. BTW, papau, Hitler destroyed the Weimar Republic

The Nazis hated the Weimar Republic and they wanted a new Bismarck style Reich.

[papau]

8. I agree - but Hitler pretended to be operating under the "consitution"!

I just put the Weimar Republic in order to note that the game does not end with a "good" constitution

as you noted - civil war remains on the table

and my fear - the Basra thugs impose Sharia, as they interpret Sharia, on the whole country - is a very real option.

[IndianaGreen]

9. Yep, and Goebbels entered the Reichstag saying...

that the goal of the Nazis was the destruction of parliamentary democracy. They sounded so... Republican!

[papau]

10. :-) true :-(

:-(