Gingrich; explaining iraq as on track and making progress is nonsense

[dajoki]

NYT 8/20/05
http://www.nytimes.com/2005/08/20/opinion/20dowd.html?th&emc=th

HEY, WHAT'S THAT SOUND

<<snip>>

"Any effort to explain Iraq as 'We are on track and making progress' is nonsense," Newt Gingrich told Adam Nagourney and David D. Kirkpatrick for a Times article on G.O.P. jitters about the shadow of Iraq over the midterm elections. "The left has a constant drumbeat that this is Vietnam and a bottomless pit. The daily and weekly casualties leave people feeling that things aren't going well."

<<snip>>

It isn't only the left that is invoking Vietnam. You know you're in trouble when Henry Kissinger gives you advice on how to exit a war.
The man who won a Nobel Peace Prize for making a botched exit and humiliating defeat look like a brilliant act of diplomacy wrote an op-ed article in The Washington Post drawing the analogy the White House dreads: Iraq as Vietnam, including an unfavorable comparison: "After the failure of Hanoi's Tet offensive, the guerrilla threat was substantially eliminated. Saigon and all other urban centers were far safer than major cities in Iraq are today."

He said Mr. Bush had only a few things to accomplish: train a real Iraqi Army that includes all religious and ethnic groups, make the Shiites stop hating the Sunnis and the Kurds stop hating everyone, and keep the Iranians from creating a theocratic dictatorship in Iraq. Oh, yeah, and a couple of other teensy little things: our troops have to defeat the vicious Iraq insurgency, and Mr. Bush needs to keep domestic support for the war.

Domestic support is waning because the president remains too stubbornly ensconced in his fantasy world - it's worse than Barbie in her dream house - to reassure Americans that he has a plan to get out.
As we approach the 2,000 mark of coffins coming home that we're not allowed to see, it doesn't even look like a war. It looks like a lot of kids being blown to smithereens by an invisible enemy

<<snip>>

Tricky Dick suggested that he had a secret plan to get out of Vietnam. Bikey W. doesn't even have a secret plan, unless it's to recreate forever, and never again have to speed past those pesky antiwar protesters in a motorcade

[hlthe2b]

1. Welcome back, Ms. Dowd....

Glad to see you've stayed on your meds with these recent columns...

(Say what you will re: Maureen's snarky past attacks on Clinton/Gore, at least she calls a spade a spade with this debaucle of a pResidency)

[dajoki]

2. agree about dowd n/t

[liberaliraqvet26]

3. If ten years ago you told me Newt Gingrich...

would be a voice of moderation I would've told you that you were nuts. Its scary how far right we are.

[OneTwentyoNine]

4. OMG,Gingrich is a genius,make everyone in Iraq stop hating each other..

Sure Newt,and I'm going to win the Powerball Lottery tonight. Jesus....