Who has the better plan for the illegal immigrants Repugs or Dems?

[Imagevision]

I've seemed to have gotten lost with this important issue with Bush geneva convention moving illegal immigrants totally off the screen.

[MannyGoldstein]

1. Hard To Say

The Republicans are all over the map. The Dems were having trouble getting a good fix to triangulate on.

[Imagevision]

2. A dem told me today he was going to vote repug because of illegal

immigrant situation is being handled better by the repugs?!! - There doesn't seem to be anything positive from either party and I figured the Rove/Reagan October surprise hasn't come down the pike yet and am still waiting to see Dems action to light up my life..

[Selatius]

3. Neither

Political correctness and business money clouds the whole debate.

If somebody came out and said they would secure the border, airports, and seaports and then set a goal of deporting several hundred thousand a year for as many years as it takes combined with a crackdown on all employers that includes fines and even jailtime, he would gain a lot of votes, in my view.

[Imagevision]

4. If employers were fined $5000. per episode, it should work like a charm

Repugs would claim business hardships for existing illegals already working in US. and GOP would claim it's bad for business??

YEAH!, exactly! that's why employers should be fined $5000.00 for first offense and $30,000 if found guilty for the second time.

[Bobbieo]

5. Neither party has a good plan - the whole thing is out of control

Years ago, the employers should have been given the max penalty instead of a slap on the wrist.

[BeFree]

6. No question....Dems

Why in the world would anyone except a freeper trust the pukes to do the right thing?