United for Peace and Justice sought to use Central Park as the site of its rally on August 29, 2004 for a variety of reasons. First, it is centrally located with adequate public transportation access. Second, it is the only place in Manhattan with large enough open spaces to accommodate a large rally. Third, the Great Lawn, as well as the North Meadow and the East Lawn, are ideal places for a large rally since, due to their shapes, all participants will be able to see and hear the speakers. Fourth, these are safe and comfortable environs, an important factor for a large rally, particularly in late August. Fifth, due to its central location, it allows UFPJ to bring its message to the people of New York. Finally, Central Park has historically been the location of major rallies and demonstrations.
On or about June 4, 2003, UFPJ filed a permit application with the New York City Parks and Recreation Department for a rally with stage and sound for the Great Lawn in Central Park. UFPJ estimated the number of participants to be 250,000. On or about December 31, 2003, UFPJ received a letter from the Parks Department stating that it was not able to make a determination as to the application at that time. The department indicated that "the presence of the Republican Convention . . . creates public safety issues which various city agencies must be prepared to meet. ... At the present time, it is too soon to know how many events are being planned and how many permit application will have to be considered for any given date and time. Consequently, decisions are being reserved until a date closer to the convention so that realistic decisions can be made concerning the number and nature of competing event."
At a meeting with the police department in late March, 2004 regarding the logistics for the planned march preceding the rally, UFPJ was advised that it would not get the use of Central Park because, it was claimed, only 80,000 people could fit in the Great Lawn. Plaintiff expressed surprise since it understood that the Parks Department would be making that decision and UFPJ had yet to have a meeting with them. The police agreed that such a meeting should take place.
http://www.rncprotestrights.org/complaint-1118932004.html