Touch-screen voting
Flagler's decision compounds problems
Last update: July 11, 2005
In the last week of June, Peggy Rae Border, Flagler County's Supervisor of Elections, requested and received $173,000 from the County Commission to buy 43 touch-screen voting machines, one for each of the county's 38 precincts. The machines won't replace Flagler's optical-scan voting system but add to it to give some disabled people the opportunity to vote privately. The machines are manufactured by Diebold Elections Systems Inc. And they produce no paper trail. If the machines malfunction at election time, there is no way to verify an electronically recorded vote against printed proof. The only verification system is the machine's own computer memory chips.
Computers are not infallible, and touch-screen machines have failed in actual elections enough times that Miami-Dade County, for example, may junk its $24.5 million investment in the technology. Border's decision nevertheless to rely on touch-screen technology in Flagler is an unfortunate concession to potential failures at a time when every supervisor should be striving for minimizing voting fiascoes, not planting the seeds for more.
Border is under pressure to comply with state law, which requires counties to have systems in place accommodating disabled voters by July 1. The law also requires that those systems be certified by the state. Diebold's is one of three systems certified. But none of the three companies on the list manufactures machines that provide a paper trail. So the state's mandate is not exactly challenge-proof. To the contrary. It forces local election supervisors into a corner while failing to achieve the law's stated aim -- equal protection for all voters.
Still, Border should have followed Volusia County's example, where the County Council chose to take a stand rather than let itself be cornered. The council refused to approve a $782,185 contract with Diebold despite threats of a lawsuit now pending in federal court. The issue is ripe for a court test. Members of the American Civil Liberties Union tried to make that point at a June 30 Palm Coast town meeting chaired by Jim O'Connell, the newest member of the Flagler County Commission. They got nowhere.
More:
http://www.news-journalonline.com/NewsJournalOnline/Opinion/Editorials/03OpOPN10071005.htm