This is what we were dealing with in Ohio. This article shows how the state’s top law official handled things: pay for play. No wonder voter suppression a massive scale took place; no wonder the recount was a joke; no wonder a top Republican fundraiser took $50 to $200 million out of state employee pension funds. ‘Special counsel’ Criticism bring Criticism of Attorney General Petro. Democrats say contributors pay to get state funded worki.
http://www.toledoblade.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20050830/NEWS24/50830001By CHRISTOPHER D. KIRKPATRICK
BLADE STAFF WRITER
August 31 2001
COLUMBUS — Democratic officials brought pay-to-play charges to the state controlling board yesterday and aimed them squarely at Republican Attorney General Jim Petro.
Two Democratic members of the board questioned awarding $19 million in outside legal work to firms that had contributed $803,000 to Mr. Petro since 1998.
Much of the legal work, which is approved by Mr. Petro, is for routine collections on behalf of state agencies. But money for other contracts also was approved yesterday to pay the legal fees caused by fallout from an investment scandal at the Ohio Bureau of Workers’ Compensation.
Called “special counsel” work, the contracts awarded yesterday and each fiscal year by Mr. Petro have been attacked by Democrats as part of a pay-to-play system highlighted this year by the bureau’s recent investment scandal, which began with problems over a $50 million investment in rare coins with former Toledo-area coin dealer Tom Noe, who was a major Republican fund-raiser.
“There’s $800,000 in contributions from the very firms we have before us,” said Sen. Ray Miller, a Columbus Democrat and controlling board member. “Why is it the lawyers that make the substantial contributions get all the special counsel work?”
Mr. Petro has said that Bernadette Noe, who is married to Tom Noe, may have lobbied the attorney general to win some special counsel work.
In 2003, Mr. Petro appointed Tracy Kidd, who like Ms. Noe was a part-time lawyer at the Toledo firm of Wise & Dorner, as special counsel to conduct some debt collection.
The appointment meant that Ms. Kidd, and potentially Ms. Noe, would receive as much as one-third of the $245,000 collected during her tenure as special counsel for the state. The standard fee for special counsel is one-third of the first $30,000 of each claim collected, and an additional 10 percent for additional collections.
Contact Christopher D. Kirkpatrick at: ckirkpatrick@theblade.com or 614-221-1766.
CLICK HERE to get quick access to Election Results and Discussion Forum on your “Latest” page.