|
Edited on Sat Dec-27-08 03:17 PM by Two Americas
Warren and other leaders of the religious right would like us to believe that they represent millions, all of whom think alike. That is an illusion he creates to dupe everyone. "I represent the Christian community." That is why selecting Warren for the invocation is so destructive, because what that does mostly is reinforce Warren's leadership position - buttress and validate and legitimatize it.
I went to a fundy church on Christmas Eve, a crowd of about 300 rural whites, all Warren admirers (his book has made him a superstar, and many people get email "update" nonsense from him and are networked in) and spoke out against bigotry. (Fortuitously for me, the main pastor was out of town on an emergency, and the congregation was winging it informally - they alternated readings of the story of "the child born in poverty, to outcast, despised unwed parents bringing a message of love" with singing traditional carols. I belted out the bass parts with gusto, and was glad they didn't do any of that swaying emotional crappy modern "Christian" music.)
A member got up and did an ad hoc homily on the theme of being a light in the darkness (living the message of love and compassion and charity in humility as an example to others) rather than presuming to shine a light into the darkness (judging your neighbor and telling them what to do.) Perfect.
Here is what I saw - those people are fearful and worried, they are blue collar working class folks, struggling and wondering if they can keep their jobs and their homes and their farms or shops. They have a sense that things have all gone terribly wrong, and they don't hear our analysis of that, they don't hear what they need to hear to make sense of things. Liberals never go there, strong left wing voices are not heard in the media. Then along comes a self-serving demagogue, like Warren, promising to make sense of it all for them and wrapping it all in a perverted and corrupted religious context. They are extraordinarily vulnerable to the lies and deception of the religious right demagogues. Warren tells them, that yes things have gone wrong and they are not at fault, and that yes things seem overwhelming and hopeless, so we turn to the message of the humble carpenter and use that as a guide for our lives. So far so good, but Warren could never attain power and influence and wealth if he stopped there. He would be a servant rather than master if he practiced what he preached. So he tells them that there is a spiritual war going on between good and evil, and then identifies the ones on the side of evil by pandering to people's fears and prejudice. "Stick with me" he says (buy my books, send money, get my newsletter) "and we will fight back against the evil together." Big fucking cynical manipulative deceitful lie right there.
I got a good response to what I had to say about homophobia and bigotry, some tearing up and people shaking my hand and hugging me afterward, and I hope a lot of people are thinking things over now. There is at least just a little crack in the armor now.
This is no big deal, I am not trying to say I did any great thing here at all. I am relating the story mostly for the benefit of other straights. I think we need to speak out, and I think it is a lot easier for straights to do this.
|