porn is degrading to women. Period.
But except in terms of raw sexual dominance, it's hardly male-empowering, either. It's a mass-marketed one-dimensional masturbatory aid that shows empty caricatures rutting. The male figures aren't men; they're bipedal vehicles for transporting their penises from one orifice to the next. Are the women degraded? Unquestionably. But the males aren't exactly role models; it's just that they're the ones doing the inserting, and that's because the product is aiming for the target demographic through the means that have proven most effective to date (and that same demographic does the vast majority of the purchasing, does it not?)
to continually say that het porn "isn't like that" and looking at the top selling and rented titles makes me think you are being disingenious or in plain old denial.
One could as readily say "I hate rap because it's all about glorifying criminal behavior," and that assessment would be accurate if one judged only that fraction of rap that gets a lot of airtime.
I can't rattle off a list of non-best-sellers in porn because I'm not exactly a connoseur, but it strikes me as invalid to summarize het porn in general on the basis of what sells well. I'm not saying that your point is wrong, either; just that your choice to frame it in terms of the top ten het titles doesn't quite work. Sales-popularity does not equate to representational sampling.
Heck, while I'm at it, it seems to me that the really nasty gonzo hardcore fringe stuff is far more degrading to women, wherein the foregrounded intent is to brutalize, humiliate, and debase the woman, rather than simply to ejaculate on, in, or near her. Perhaps mainstream stuff is more insidious for its seemingly less degrading style, but if we pursue that logic then we
must extend the discussion to mainstream media in general (as, I believe, bloom has done elsewhere in this thread).
Why, for example, do the women on
Dancing With The Stars flit about the stage while three-quarters naked, yet the men stride around in suits? Is this not a form of sex-based dominance, especially since the males in this context are
leading? Similar examples abound.
Popular het porn may be the crystalization of the phenomenon, but I'm not sure that it's the most egregious offender.