opinions

[rdking647]

playing around at town lake. tried a few different edits. comments/criticisms/suggestions????

[Mira]

1. Mine: Natural makes me the happiest. In this case: number two works for me.

Wish I were there in a kayak. My local lake is drained for repairs of the dam. It looks a lot like that.

[HarveyDarkey]

2. I agree with Mira

#2 is my favorite also. You can really see the ripples in the water.

[Mz Pip]

3. I like #4

It's soft and natural.

[alfredo]

4. 1 and 2 look processed. 3, not so much. 4 looks more natural to me.

So my choice would be 4 with 3 a close second.

[Stevenmarc]

5. 4 is the most natural

2 would be my choice if it were pulled back a bit so you can't see the halo'ing in the sky. 3 has a bit of an Orton'esque thing going on which works better on a more defined subject.

[ManiacJoe]

6. The pics are a little small to judge from, but....

The brightness in #1 would print well.

#2 and #4 look good on screen, the difference in the sharpness of the detail depending on the mood you are looking for.

#3 looks way too vibrant. Too much loss of detail, maybe? The brightness would probably print well.