I'm planning for a future system, our HOA will not allow solar hot water systems (Texas, go figure). This is for our "downsized" retirement home in a few years. I'll be making a DIY system due to the high cost of the "commercially available" systems so I can design it any way I want.
I've seen a number of youtube videos that show a grid of connected tubes with no set path from inlet at the bottom (the low end) to the outlet at the top (the high end). These videos show the water (or heat transfer fluid if a coil system) flowing from bottom to top by heat convection only. I'd always thought that there had to be a pump involved to push the water through the system, an active system, where the water travels through a single loop from inlet to output.
Here's an example of a passive system, showing the thermosiphon effect with red dye in the water:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=haXK_-rmzFY&feature=related...takes about 2 minutes for the water to cycle from the cold inlet to the hot outlet (at 2:30 in the timeline).
Compare that to an active system which uses a water pump to circulate the heat transfer fluid:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YBfOfcaOFWw&NR=1... or:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D-ZpzDntsZ0&NR=1...solar panel powers the water pump so any of these systems are "off the grid" as far as that goes.
My question is: which way is better? Which one heats the water fastest or gets it hottest?
PS, here in Dallas we get plenty of sun during the day even in the dead of winter and I'll have plenty of roof space to put the solar collectors so if one doesn't do the trick I can put up two, three, four, however many I'll need. Also, the water will be from a well, filtered first and then pumped into an underground cistern or a very well insulated water tower (I'm uncertain how much water pressure I can get with a solar powered pump, thus the tower). If I go the tower route, the solar water collectors will be bolted onto the tower with solar collectors/wind turbine atop the whole thing to power the water pumps and sensors (which will wirelessly report water temperature, water level in the tank, etc.)