<snip>
Thursday, July 5, 2007
Wall Street Journal on Crooked Mortgage Broker
Today's Wall Street Journal, in "Mortgage Mess Shines Light on Brokers' Role," tells the sorry tale of one Altaf A. Shaikh, who frequently used the name Zak Khan and left a path of financial devastation in his wake as a subprime mortgage broker.
This isn't a great job of reporting. By focusing on one, and only one, likely criminal mortgage broker (civil and criminal suits are pending), the Journal creates the impression that, to the extent there were abuses in subprime lending, they were the doing of a few sharks like Shaikh who were able to operate freely in a rapidly growing and lightly regulated industry, in which many of the players were not well managed.
The piece fails even to acknowledge that at some firms, the practices that have been called "mis-selling" and might less charitably be called "ripping off ignorant customers" have more than occasionally occurred at the institutional level. And not just at Orange County bucket shops either.
For example, in 2002, Household International entered into a $484 million settlement for predatory lending practices involving subprime mortgages. Mortgage broker Ameriquest reached a $325 million settlement in early 2006 for deceptive consumer lending practices and was also required to adopt many new practices, including scripted language for oral disclosures. Even so, affordable housing expert Doug Smith noted that the cost of the Ameriquest settlement was a mere slap on the wrist and provided an average recovery of only a few hundred dollars each to defrauded customers, many of whom had lost their homes. And Argent, Ameriquest's biggest subprime subsidiary, was exempt from the reforms . The State of Ohio charged now bankrupt mortgage lender New Century with a variety of violations of consumer sales and mortgage brokerage regulations, including making false and misleading statements, accepting loan processing payments even though the company knew it did not have the money to fund them, and failing to act in good faith.
<MUCH MORE>
http://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2007/07/wall-street-journal-on-crooked-mortgage.html