digby dug up a r/w article on Eric Holder...

[babylonsister]

and this was written as criticism!

http://digbysblog.blogspot.com/2008/11/top-cop-by-digby-eric-holder-as-ag.html

Top Cop

by digby

Eric Holder as AG sounds like an excellent choice to me. Check out what Jerome Corsi had to say about him in Newsmax last June:

Calling Guantanamo Bay an "international embarrassment," Eric H. Holder, Jr., one of the two remaining appointees on Barack Obama's vice presidential search team, said the next president must close the detention facility and transfer prisoners to military prisons.

In a speech given Friday evening to the American Constitution Society convention in Washington, D.C., Holder charged, "For the last 6 years the position of leader of the Free World has been largely vacant."

In his half-hour address culminating in a standing ovation from the 350 attendees in the audience, Holder made no reference to the scandals which have forced Washington insider Jim Johnson to resign from Obama' vice presidential search committee or to the controversial role he played as deputy attorney general pushing the Marc Rich pardon in the closing days of the Clinton administration.

Instead, in his Friday evening speech at the ACS convention, Holder devoted his entire time to criticizing the Bush administration on the conduct of the war on terror, strongly suggesting that a President Obama would pursue a rights-oriented approach to dealing with suspected terrorists and captured enemy combatants.

Holder charged the detention facility at Guantanamo Bay was a "moral hazard," which he compared to the original constitutional flaw that permitted slavery to continue, to President Lincoln's decision to suspend habeas corpus during the Civil War and to the decision by President Franklin Roosevelt to create the Japanese internment camps during World War II.

"We have squandered one of our greatest strengths as a nation," Holder said, taking a partisan swipe at the Bush administration.

He insisted it was disgraceful that the Supreme Court "had to order the president to treat detainees in accord with the Geneva Convention."

In the months and years since 9/11, the Bush administration took many steps that were excessive and unlawful," Holder continued. "We authorized torture and we let fear take precedence over the rule of law, as we overreacted to perceived danger."

In addition to closing Gitmo, Holder insisted the next president should:

* Declare without qualification a policy that the United States will not torture political detainees, engage in forced interrogations or submit people to degrading treatment in prison;

* End all programs, covert or otherwise, to transfer detainees to nations that practice torture;

* Stop domestic search and seizures without warrant and end wiretapping of citizens.

"We have lost our way before," Holder told the 350 attendees at the Friday evening session. "Now we must step back into the shining path envisioned by our founding fathers in such icons of liberty as the Declaration of Independence, the Constitution and the Bill of Rights."

"There is evil in the world and we face grave threats to our national security," Holder admitted, "but we must reclaim our moral leadership by no longer letting fear rule our reactions."

"When the new administration takes over on January 20, 2009, we will be looking for folks who share our values," he proclaimed, assuming Barack Obama would defeat John McCain.

That was all meant as criticism of Holder, by the way.

According to Pete Williams on MSNBC, they vetted him with GOP Senators about the Marc Rich nonsense and he will be confirmed without a lot of drama. If he follows through on what he says above it would be good news.

[mucifer]

1. well that makes me feel a little better about him.

[babylonsister]

2. Then I'm happy to have posted it! nt

[Libertyfirst]

3. Thank God, an Attorney General who knows we have a constitution. n/t