Don't scapegoat the teachers

[proud2BlibKansan]

Don't scapegoat the teachers

To help students, they need tools, time and trust from administrators.
By Randi Weingarten

Applauding the mass firings at Central Falls High School — despite the real progress underway — is the latest clarion call by the blame-the-teacher crowd. Rather than sharing responsibility, administrators there chose to scapegoat the teachers who have helped bring about double-digit gains in student achievement at the struggling school.

The "fire them all" approach doesn't reflect the complexity of teaching in challenging schools. In their quest for a silver bullet, administrators instead are chasing what experience shows is a failed approach.

Central Falls High School teachers should be lauded for helping to boost reading and writing scores by 22% and 14%, respectively, over the past two years, despite the disruptive turnover in principals, assistant principals and programs with each new administrator. The school board and superintendent should have asked what they could do to help good teachers become great teachers. Teachers need tools, time and trust from administrators to help students succeed.

Great teaching is a crucial, although not the sole, element in a child's education. Teachers believe that they should be heldaccountable, along with others. That's why the Central Falls teachers agreed months before any threat of firing to work collaboratively with school administrators to develop rigorous and fair teacher evaluations and put in place reform programs proven to boost achievement.

Speaking of accountability, let's bust some myths about tenure. Tenure is not a lifetime job guarantee, nor should it be. It ensures a fair hearing before a teacher can be disciplined or fired. School districts need to get serious about properly developing and evaluating teachers. If a teacher is deemed ineffective after being given appropriate support and assistance, then he or she should choose a different profession.

We agree that when teachers are accused of misconduct, they should be removed from the classroom immediately and these cases should be dealt with much faster. The American Federation of Teachers is working with Kenneth Feinberg, known as a master problem-solver, to develop a fair, efficient protocol for dealing with these cases.

The bottom line is that every child needs a well-prepared teacher. We're doing our part by helping to revamp teacher development, evaluation and due process. Now we need others to do their part. Our students deserve nothing less.

Randi Weingarten is president of the American Federation of Teachers.

http://blogs.usatoday.com/oped/2010/03/opposing-view-dont-scapegoat-the-teachers.html#more

[donco6]

1. We have a turnover of 21% in our district.

When you have a young staff, and you're in a high-poverty area, people make choices during that period of their lives. They get married, they have kids, they make choices about where they really want to spend their career. So we lose a lot of people.

But according to this "fire all the teachers and replace with new so the scores will go up" philosophy - our scores should be the highest in the GALAXY!

They're not.

[proud2BlibKansan]

11. Ours has dropped in the last few years

It's too hard to find a teaching job.

[endless october]

2. teachers are great Americans.

i got a great public school education because my parents required me to actively participate in that education. many of my teachers were awesome.

[jody]

3. But some teachers are not effective. I've experienced first hand teachers who did not understand the

basic concepts of mathematics who taught advanced math in high school.

My question is how to get teachers like that our of public schools so good teachers can do their job?

[proud2BlibKansan]

4. Mass firing is not the solution

That's the point of the op ed piece.

[jody]

5. IMO mass firings should be aggressively applied by voters to elected officials. n/t

[proud2BlibKansan]

9. +1

[Bozita]

6. In pro sports, the billionaire owners don't fire their losing teams. They fire the guys who run 'em.

Superintendent Gallo deserves a trip down to the unemployment office. She can be replaced by a younger, more enthusiastic leader with fresh, new ideas.

[proud2BlibKansan]

10. And a lower salary too!!

LOL

Teach for America superintendents. :rofl:

[The Genealogist]

12. Is the fact that "some teachers are not effective"

really a good argument for firing a whole school full of teachers? I know that there are bad teachers out there.

At 36 I still remember some of my own teachers being bad, and that there were some other really rotten teachers in the school.
But that does not excuse firing the whole school. Why? In high school, I also had some excellent teachers, teachers that changed the way I looked at the world and the subjects they taught.

I think I have seen it mentioned in other threads on DU about teaching and teachers that even students can identify a lousy teacher. By this I don't mean "a mean one" or "one that gives me too much homework." What I mean is that even students can tell when a teacher is failing to teach. If students can, why can't administrators? Ineffective teachers need to be identified and removed. Effective teachers need to be rewarded, NOT removed in some sort of a mass firing temper-tantrum.

[athenasatanjesus]

7. umm without scapegoats we would have to find real solutions

and those are tough.

[stray cat]

8. Scapegoat the students and parents - all 92% of them who fail basic math

Of course we did have a few wonderful teacher who threw bones at the heads of students.

[raccoon]

13. Off to Greatest with you! nt