http://blog.buzzflash.com/carpenter/622Submitted by pmcarpenter on Mon, 03/15/2010 - 4:25am.
* P.M. Carpenter
THE FIFTH COLUMNIST by P.M. Carpenter
Bear with me. This is a bit dry, but relevant -- more relevant than many appreciate.
In the mid-1950s, Bill Buckley founded the National Review in response to a crisis: conservatism, as broadly defined, could not in fact be broadly defined, except in terms of internal warring. For too long, as Buckley and his strategic lieutenants saw it, Burkean "traditionalists" and economic conservatives had been at each other's throat, producing a fault line which manifested in electoral drag.
And this, thought Buckley & Co., simply had to stop.
To the counterintuitive rescue: former Marxist Frank Meyer, who began mapping in the National Review and other conservative publications a means to right-wing unification and ultimate electoral victory. And in discovery of the winning path, Meyer had only to go home to Mama: the dialectic.
By 1960 he was insisting that conservatism's traditionalist and libertarian camps were indeed in fundamental agreement, yet each -- and this is the relevant key -- was so self-righteously cocksure of what it alone postured as philosophically "decisive," a self-destructive "distortion" set in; which is to say, each side took its dogma to exclusive extremes, refusing necessary compromise and accommodation -- necessary, that is, if ultraconservatives were ever to gain electoral dominance.