I'll give you my take on your points:
It presumes that asset managers would sell treasuries to chase commodities. Is that what they would do? Is that what they've been doing? Treasuries are still considered, world wide, one of the safest places for your money. So would they sell off other assets first? Would the Chinese be the ones to start buying them, not the feds, because THEY want to shore up what they already have?My logic here is that you are correct in implying that haven't been selling treasuries to chase commodities in the past. But in an environment where the Fed's specified goal of maintaining low yield Treasuries coincides with what the author describes as "the bond markets’ fear that there’s a “Treasury bubble”", there is the chance that a sudden rise in the price of oil might spark this type of sell-off. I'm not 100% on that, because I think the weakest part of the blog post is when after summing up this hypothetical market activity, he compares it to a recent event:
It will be a flash panic—much like the flash-crash of last May. The events I describe above will happen in a very short span of time—less than an hour, probably. But unlike the event in May, there will be no rebound.I'm not sure what's changed between now and May. Perhaps he's referring to the fear of a "Treasury bubble", but it's not clear.
On to another point you made:
Unlike every other currency that he wants to draw a comparison, the US dollar is a major currency in the world. Other currencies are as "tied" (economically speaking) to ours such that when ours goes down, so does everyone elses. Yes, there could be a run on gold, or oil but they would begin to hit highs that would make them "bubble like" and would take pressure OFF of the treasuries. The german mark wasn't in that position, folks just went to other currencies. The Japanese yen was the same way. No on was going to run BACK to the yen when commodities got too high. But if the dollar gets way outta whack, there aren't alot of other currencies for people to run to, and they'll only run to metals, pork bellies and oil until THEY are perceived as a bubble.This is something I find particularly scary, because Lira does refer to the fact that there are no other currencies by derisively scoffing at the euro: "By the end of that terrible day, commodites of all stripes—precious and industrial metals, oil, foodstuffs—will shoot the moon. But it will not be because ordinary citizens have lost faith in the dollar (that will happen in the days and weeks ahead)—it will happen because once Treasuries are not the sure store of value, where are all those money managers supposed to stick all these dollars? In a big old vault? Under the mattress? In
euros?" (emphasis in original) The author did not make reference to the Weimar Republic, I did because that's the only historical reference that comes close to comparing to the blog post hypothetical. But even that wheel-barrow-full-of-currency visual might not come close to comparison because you're right: folks in the 20's did have other currencies to go to besides the German mark. I believe most of the stronger currencies at that time were on the gold standard. Now they're all tied to the dollar. So what happens when the world's reserve currency is debased? Worldwide hyperinflation? Speaking of bubbles, there's a conservatively estimated $85 trillion derivatives bubble which Warren Buffett refers to as
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/2817995.stm">"financial weapons of mass destruction" that outprices whatever commodities bubble might balloon in the wake of hyperinflation. What happens when all those worthless dollars come back home from overseas countries that no longer need our stinkin' dollars?!
There are risks for sure, and we are in very rough political and economic times. And we could see something along the line he is talking about, a concern by the TBTF banks looking to spread their risks around. But honestly, they don't have alot of places to go.
When all is said and done, I'm far more worried about deflation. But that's probably because I owe money. This guy is holding money, so he's worried about it.Rough political and economic times now and in the future, for sure. Honestly, I'm not sure which scenario is more likely. I'm very worried about deflation myself, there's a great column by Paul Krugman detailing exactly how deflation is
http://www.chron.com/disp/story.mpl/editorial/outlook/7146458.html">decimating our infrastructure. But I think the possibility of hyperinflation can not be completely dismissed. Whether you're holding money or not (I don't have much besides a leaky 401k), I think the concern is legitimate.