As far as politics is concerned, the issue of this thread is not of great significance; but I thought it would be interesting to hopefully have a discussion about it. I guess I should provide info relevant to my point of view. I’m a 60-year-old man who has never been a sports fan, but I have been working with a personal trainer at a local health club on a bodybuilding program for over two years. I work out four times a week. On “off” days I usually take a brisk, hour-long walk. The point is that I’m very active physically. I’m not a coach potato. As a matter of fact, I hardly watch any TV. Don’t have time for it. Several close friends of mine are former high-school football players, one of whom played football at SUNY in Buffalo, New York, from the fall of 1965 through the fall of 1968.
As a new member of this website, I’ve been fascinated by the rift between those DUers who are sports fans and those who say that they don’t like or even hate sports. There seems to be no communication and therefore no understanding between the two sides. Just the online equivalent of yelling, which seems to be the norm in most website forums.
One point needs to be made first. There is no point in arguing over one's preference. He likes Neapolitan ice cream, but she likes chocolate. One really cannot argue the merits of which is better. My older daughter, who graduated last year from a university in Texas with a degree in math, had enjoyed attending the football games. Even though I don't even know how the game is played, I had no problem with her being a fan.
The sports culture has been a preoccupation of mine for years. Notice that I make a distinction between a sport, especially a school sport, and the culture that is associated with it (but is not inherently a part of it). Regarding sports fans and those who don't like sports, I've noticed that there is intolerance on
both sides.
One DUer said at another post, "There are ALOT of anti-sports people on DU Mostly because they think its beneath them! I get it if you don't like it, but stop with the elitist snobbery. See, I don't get how the party that prides itself on tolerance has soooo many people who spend their time belittling others...." I don't ridicule someone simply because he likes sports.
But what about the belittling of nonathletic boys who frequently are bullied simply because they have no interest in sports? I would think that liberals would be concerned about this. Masculinity is now defined solely in terms of athletic prowess. Nonathletic boys and men are viewed as effete and effeminate. The social stigmatization often begins before the boys have even reached puberty. Never mind that there have been extremely courageous men who never had any interest in sports. Ever hear of Raoul Wallenberg (not to mention many others)? Boys who have no interest in sports are often suspected of having homosexual tendencies. (Ever hear of Brian Sims or Esera Tuaolo?) I'm amazed that this lie has persisted to this day.
The following link accesses an interesting post about "sports wound" written by a clinical psychologist.
http://americanmentalhealthfoundation.org/entry.php?id=135I've noticed that a number of the DU men were bullied by "jocks" when they were in school (a subject which, incidentally, has never been reported by the sports media -- except by the sportswriter Robert Lipsyte). Let me emphasize that I
don't believe that the majority of school athletes are bullies, but there do seem to be more than enough to make a difference. Do a site search on "jock bullies" and take the time to check out the links. Some, obviously, aren't relevant to the issue (such as those mentioning "shock jocks"). These are really sad stories. Are all of these DUers lying?
Here is a sample:
I went to a southern rural football high-school. I got beat mostly because I was bad at sports. We always played competitive sports at P.E. Missing a catch or striking out nearly always got me roughed up.
There is no rationale that justifies a kid being in physical danger at school. I remember fighting with a couple of football players, I never stood a chance and all the kids stood around and watched as they pushed my face into the dirt and kicked me in the balls so hard that I threw up. The teacher did nothing because the football heroes had a game and didn't want to suspend them. I hated the bullies, the teachers, and all of kids who stood there and laughed at my humiliation. I still hate jocks.
What set them off? I said "lighten up, It's only a game." I guess I was asking for it.
I wonder if any of the DU sports fans have read any of these posts. Sad to say, I've not come across a single post by a DU sports fan expressing any sympathy to any of these guys.
Here is a link to a webpage that provides another example of bullying in sports. (Yes, this happened in Great Britain; but it's still relevant.) Question: Has the issue of the bullying of nonathletic boys by athletic fellow students ever been discussed at any sports psychology or sports sociology website?
http://www.bullyonline.org/cases/case97.htmTwo friends of mine who are about my age were forced when they were in school to take sports-centered P.E.,
even though they were physically handicapped. Both of them were bullied relentlessly by athlete classmates, and none of the coaches cared. When one of my friends eventually retaliated against one of his bullies by slamming his head against a wall in the lockerroom, the coach punished my nonathletic friend instead of the bully because the bully was an athlete. (But at least the bullying stopped.) Should anyone be surprised that these two friends of mine have deep-rooted feelings against sports?
Victims of this sort of bullying often make the mistake of negatively stereotyping all athletes instead of recognizing that some don't even subscribe to machismo. They also wrongly transfer their resentment to the appreciation that others have for sports.
When someone makes an outrageous (yes, I did say "outrageous") statement such as "football is evil," seemingly many of the DU sports fans go ballistic. In other words, their reaction is excessive. A more rational reaction would be to just shrug it off as a comment made by a lonely crank. But the observation must be made that those who hate sports have no power (in
most situations). But the sports fans
do have power. For generations nonathletic boys have been bullied and humiliated in "sports only" P.E. classes that have NOT provided exercise programs for them. And as far as sports fans getting upset over
a single individual saying that sports should be banned from schools, is there such a movement to remove sports as extracurricular activities from schools? Are sports threatened by such statements? Of course, not. So, why the excessive reaction?
What has exasperated me is that sports fans have ascribed the basest motives to anyone who objects to any of the excesses of the sports culture, as if no one finding fault with the sports culture could possibly have any legitimate point of view. On the other hand, those who have been hurt by the sports culture should guard against sinking to the level of those who bullied or otherwise mistreated them. There are legitimate points on both sides. The DUers who are sports fans and those who resent sports should listen to each other.